Killing or sparing Arnold doesn't change the story in GTA 6. What it changes is Jason's Criminal Profile: shoot him and the rating leans Hardened, let him go and it leans Restrained. Game Rant reports that the scene after the docks plays the same either way, with Jason telling Brian that Arnold won't cause any more trouble (Game Rant). PowerPyx also says the outcome is the same and lists no reward for either choice (PowerPyx).
The two choices#
| Choice | What happens | Criminal Profile |
|---|---|---|
| Shoot Arnold | You take the shot at the docks | Hardened |
| Spare Arnold | He swims away | Restrained |
| Wait and do nothing | The game picks for you and he swims away | Restrained |
The ratings come from Game Rant. Once Arnold is in the water you can't shoot him anymore, so the choice is made at the moment the prompt appears.
Which should you pick#
Pick the one that fits the Jason you want to play. Neither choice adds a mission, a trophy or a reward in the walkthroughs we checked, and either way Brian moves on to Kenton, which starts Island Dreams. The Criminal Profile is the only lasting difference, and one choice is a small part of it. How the ratings add up is in Criminal Profile explained.
The full mission, from the pool bar to the chase on Maroon Key, is in the Hey Arnold! walkthrough.
FAQ#
Should you kill or spare Arnold in GTA 6?
It's your call. The story is the same either way. Shooting him pushes Jason's profile towards Hardened, sparing him towards Restrained.
Does sparing Arnold matter?
Only for the Criminal Profile, as far as current guides show. PowerPyx says Arnold leaves the game for good whichever you pick.
What happens if you don't choose?
The game makes the choice after a short wait. Arnold swims away and you get the Restrained rating.
Does Arnold come back later?
Not in PowerPyx's playthrough, which says he's never seen again.
Is there a trophy for killing Arnold?
No trophy or reward is tied to either choice in the guides above.
Every story mission in order is on the missions page.



