Arthur Morgan's hat is at a yard sale on Orchard Avenue in southern Port Gellhorn, once you reach Chapter 2. Look for a blue house with an American flag out front: the hat sits on a guitar case on the sofa by the flagpole, and it's sold as a Genuine Cowboy Hat. Most guides give the price as $35 (Gfinity, Into Indie Games). IGN shared the spot on launch day (IGN on X).

No story spoilers here, only when the yard sale opens up.

Quick answer#

Where A yard sale at a blue house on Orchard Avenue, southern Port Gellhorn
What to look for A brown hat with a rope band, on a guitar case on the sofa next to the flagpole
Name in the game Genuine Cowboy Hat
Price $35 in most guides, a few say $5
When From Chapter 2, when the story reaches Port Gellhorn
Who can wear it Reported for both Jason and Lucia

How to get it#

  1. Reach Chapter 2. Port Gellhorn opens up for the story here. Our Port Gellhorn guide covers the town.
  2. Drive to Orchard Avenue in the south of town and look for the blue house with the flag and a yard sale on the lawn.
  3. Check the sofa by the flagpole. The hat is on top of a guitar case. Its rope band is the giveaway (TheGamer).
  4. Buy it and wear it from your wardrobe like any other hat.

Is it really Arthur's hat?#

The game never says so. The item text calls it a Genuine Cowboy Hat and doesn't mention Arthur or Red Dead (Gfinity). The shape, the colour and the knotted band match the hat Arthur wears in Red Dead Redemption 2, and Rockstar has left nods to its western before, so most players read it as a tribute.

Where guides disagree#

  • The price. Most say $35, a few early posts say $5. The tag on the table is what counts.
  • Who sees it. One guide says it only appears while you play as Lucia in Chapter 2, others say it's in the Cowboy Hats list for both. If it isn't there for one of them, switch and come back.
  • The place. One write-up says it's in the starting area, but every other guide puts it in Port Gellhorn.

More Red Dead nods#

There's also a Western novel set in New Austin, Red Dead's frontier state, at Jason's place early on. Both are on our easter egg hub, and the two games are compared in GTA 6 vs Red Dead 2. Clothes shops and wardrobes are in clothes, hair and tattoos, and the completion side of outfits is in styles, watches and tattoos on our collectibles site.